REALTOR® Reviews
William Tarantola
We recently sold our home of 28 years in Dix Hills thanks to the hard work and expertise of William Tarantola. William walked us through the entire process from staging our home to hosting an open house to negotiating a full asking price sale in ten days!! He was sensitive to our feelings and needs and made what could have been a traumatic experience, especially during COVID, a seamless painless process. He goes above and beyond what anyone would expect your real estate agent to do. We couldn't be happier! Hara and Mike Cohen
William Tarantola
William has handled sales and purchased for myself and my children of many years. He is professional, honest and knowns the real estate business like no other realtor. He has always been a pleasure to work with and would recommend him to anyone who wants a professional marketing genius.
William Tarantola
We got the asking price for our home in less than three weeks, after other close bids, and it is entirely due to the efforts of William Tarantola. Before even coming to meet with us and see our home, he learned all there was to know about our property and our neighborhood. When he came over, he saw every positive feature of our home, many of which we did not even appreciate, and made us feel that our home was a true treasure and worth top dollar. We had the pleasure of seeing him in action; he brought only pre-qualified people who were genuinely interested in buying. He met each buyer at the door and walked them through the house, showing the house through his eyes, allowing them to see its best features and its potential, never pushing, only illuminating. If you have been home shopping, as we are now, and seen other agents in action, you may have noticed how they mostly stand around like lumps and know little about the places they are selling. You will be floored by the contrast seeing William do the job. While being scrupulously accurate in every statement he makes about the property, having all information at his fingertips, he educates the buyers about the unique features of the home, conveying the information with exuberant positive energy and enthusiasm. I am absolutely certain that no one else could have marketed our house as well. He left us feeling that our home was valued fairly, and that the love and improvements we put in are valued by our buyer. On a personal note, I am a big fan. William is a delightful person to know, so smart, savvy, funny, ethical and honest in a business not known for those qualities, and the consummate professional. After an agent from another agency was rude and dismissive and sought to make a quick sale on the cheap of our house, a friend recommended William, as he sold the house of an acquaintance of ours in days for a great price, after the house had been languishing on the market for more than a year, with three agents who utterly failed to generate any interest in it. I am absolutely indebted to that friend. Working with William Tarantola was a great experience, and I recommend him without reservation. Marlene Schwarz
William Tarantola
Hello, I wanted to give you some insight as to our experience working with William Tarantola. This was my fiance's and my first time buying a house so we were a bit anxious about the process in general. We started our search on Trulia and Zillow and had a few experiences working with the brokers that were attached to those listings. Working with those brokers only heightened our anxiety in this process. They were overly aggressive, didn't listen to our concerns, uninformative, and it was easy to tell they were just looking to make the sale. Our experience with William couldn't have been more of the opposite. We first met William by cold calling a listing that we found, he was listed as the selling agent. William made himself available for us to see the particular listing, accommodating both of our busy and unusual schedules. As we walked into the property, we knew that the house we were in was not going to be for us but we wanted to remain respectful to both William and the seller so we completed the tour. William was able to pick up on my fiance's body language and general lack of excitement and he could tell that we wanted something different. After leaving the showing William offered to help us on our journey and didn't pressure us in the slightest, which to me was exactly what I was looking for. I wanted to work with a broker that was knowledgeable, respectful, and wasn't trying to shove every listing down our throats. This was William. William got us set up on prospect and we began seeing a large amount of listings come our way. After going to about 7-10 showings with William, we hadn't found anything that we loved. Thought the process William was really on our side. Asking the necessary questions to the sellers or the sellers brokers, questions that first time home buyers wouldn't know to ask. He made sure we were protected throughout the entire process and for that I am grateful. We finally found the house of our dreams about 4-5 weeks into the process with William and made an offer. William helped us make an informed initial offer and help us through the negotiation process. Through having our offer accepted to moving into our house about 2 weeks ago, William never stopped working for us. I was able to call him at any hour and he was there to answer my questions or ease my concerns. I honestly couldn't be happier that we found William and wouldn't want to work with anyone else in the future. I will recommend him to all of my family and friends who are in the market. A 12 out of 10. Please feel free to reach out if you have any questions or would like any further information. Best, Cody
William Tarantola
I knew I would be recommending and writing a 5 star review for William Tarantola from our very first conversation. He " held my hand" , guided me and helped me make the right decision . Today I am one very happy home owner! I cannot tell you how many houses we saw together, I lost count, but with every house we saw, I was thankful that I had him there with me, because he examined every inch of the house in detail as if he was buying it for himself. The care he showed made me feel like I was part of his family and by the end of the year I started calling him...uncle William..and I still do. He really is...the best realtor. Fay
William Tarantola
I am delighted to be writing this letter in praise of our agent, William Tarantola. He was an absolute pleasure to have on our side as we navigated the challenges of selling the home that had been in our family for 50 plus years. He is a great communicator; incredibly responsive, knowledgeable and detail oriented. William guided us through every step of the sale - from preparing for the staging, showings, all of the offers, through to the contract, inspections and final sale with enthusiasm, compassion and humor. The house sold for over asking solely due to William's efforts. Thank you- for all of your hard work, for putting your heart into this process, and for your perseverance. We are delighted. Miriam Hertzson
William Tarantola
Thank you, William! Mr. Tarantola is an excellent real estate agent. He cares about his clients, and always makes himself available for questions or concerns. He definitely knows the business. He put us in touch with all the right people to help us purchase our house. We're thrilled with the results and so grateful that we now have a team of experts that we can rely on. Fantastic service that cares!
William Tarantola
After closing On my new house I am truly confident I worked with the best. Not just the best agent but the best team. William and his agency were one step ahead of everything which made every part of the process a success. Constant contact, updates and true care and concern were what I was provided. The knowledge, confidence and experience William has sets him apart from anyone else. I am a little upset it's all over for now but I plan on keeping in touch and referring anyone interested in only working with the best professionals.
William Tarantola
I am writing a review for one of your RE agents, Mr. William Tarantola, who has provided a service to me recently at 258 Hallock Rd, Stony Brook, NY. I have been Chairman in my department for years, so I understand that a director may want to know how a department member is perceived by others. I asked him to let me know the name of the CEO/Administrator of Coach Realtors because I wish to share my experience with you and other potential clients, who might be wondering where to find excellent service. Since the contract was signed, it was a long journey of almost ten weeks with a few bumps but he has been consistent with staying positive, communicating superbly, co-ordinating very well, and prevailed on everyone to move forward. In sum, I am pleased to report that William is deserving of excellent commendation. I happened to work with more than a dozen R/E agents in the past 30 years. In my unbiased understanding, without a single moment of hesitation, he is an outstanding agent in this field of RE business. He is a congenial, trustworthy, precise person and one to be respected for an extremely fine ability of professionalism and creativity in a polite manner. He seems to be an equalizer in times of work-related problem-solving. He would advise what to do and what not to do. It certainly takes an emotionally stable and mature person to express that quality. It is my honest opinion that Mr. William Tarantola is competent and caring. I strongly and unequivocally endorse him without any reservations to any client.
William Tarantola
Good afternoon Mrs. Finn, I just wanted to take a moment to provide feedback on my experience with William as our agent for the sale of 101 Cypress Dr. Kings Park, NY. William's vast real estate experience and expertise to be indispensable in guiding us through the sale of home in the midst of the covid pandemic while relocating our family to Atlanta, Georgia. William ensured that the property was photographed and listed promptly and professionally and that all covid safety protocols were followed, his understanding of the unique market conditions resulted in our home selling for 40K over asking in less than one week. We could not be happier with the results, William made our dreams come true, I am thankful he was our agent. Sincerely, Gregory Lee
ARCHIVES
-
2026 | 3 REALTOR® Reviews
- March 2026 | 3 Reviews
-
2025 | 3 REALTOR® Reviews
- July 2025 | 1 Review
- October 2025 | 2 Reviews
-
2024 | 2 REALTOR® Reviews
- October 2024 | 2 Reviews
-
2023 | 1 REALTOR® Review
- August 2023 | 1 Review
-
2022 | 4 REALTOR® Reviews
- February 2022 | 1 Review
- March 2022 | 1 Review
- September 2022 | 1 Review
- November 2022 | 1 Review
-
2020 | 2 REALTOR® Reviews
- January 2020 | 1 Review
- November 2020 | 1 Review
-
2018 | 1 REALTOR® Review
- August 2018 | 1 Review
-
2015 | 3 REALTOR® Reviews
- February 2015 | 1 Review
- June 2015 | 1 Review
- September 2015 | 1 Review
-
2013 | 1 REALTOR® Review
- November 2013 | 1 Review
SALES ASSOCIATES
- Nicole Artemis Aslani... | 1 Review
- William Tarantola | 25 Reviews
- William Tarantola & N... | 4 Reviews
